Sunday, September 17, 2017

To love the least among the lowly

There was a sort of twinkle in Jung’s eye that gave me the impression that he knew himself to be just as much a villain as everybody else. There is a nice German word, hintergedanken, which means a thought in the very far far back of your mind. Jung had a hintergedanken in the back of his mind that showed in the twinkle in his eye. It showed that he knew and recognized what I’ve sometimes called the element of irreducible rascality in himself. And he knew it so strongly and so clearly, and in a way so lovingly, that he would not condemn the same thing in others, and would therefore not be lured into those thoughts, feelings, and acts of violence towards others which are always characteristic of the people who project the devil in themselves upon the outside; upon somebody else, upon the scapegoat.

Now this made Jung a very integrated character… In other words, he was man who was thoroughly “with himself.” Having seen and accepted his own nature profoundly he had a kind of a unity and absence of conflict in his own nature which had to exhibit additional complications that I find so fascinating. He was the sort of man who could feel anxious and afraid and guilty without being ashamed of feeling this way. In other words, he understood that an integrated person is not a person who’s simply eliminated the sense of guilt or the sense of anxiety from his life; who is fearless and wooden and a kind of sage of stone. He is a person who feels all these things but has no recriminations against himself for feeling them. And this is to my mind a profound kind of humor. You know in humor there is always a certain element of malice. There was a talk given on the Pacifica stations just a little while ago which was an interview with Al Capp. And Al Capp made the point that he felt that all humor was fundamentally malicious.

Now there’s a very high kind of humor which is humor at oneself. Real humor is not jokes at the expense of others, it’s always jokes at the expense of oneself. Of course it has an element of malice in it. It has malice towards oneself; the recognition of the fact that behind the social role that you assume - behind all your pretentions to being either a good citizen or a fine scholar or a great scientist or a leading politician or a physician or whatever you happen to be - that behind this façade there is a certain element of the unreconstructed bum. Not as something to be condemned and wailed over but as something to be recognized as contributive to one’s greatness and to one’s positive aspect in the same way that manure is contributive to the perfume of the rose.

Jung saw this and Jung accepted this and I want to read a passage from one of this lectures, which I think is one of the greatest things he ever wrote and which has been a very marvelous thing for me. It was in a lecture delivered to a group of clergy in Switzerland a considerable number of years ago and he writes as follows:

"People forget that even doctors have moral scruples and that certain patient’s confessions are hard even for a doctor to swallow. Yet the patient does not feel himself accepted unless the very worst of him is accepted too. No one can bring this about by mere words. It comes only through reflection and through the doctor’s attitude towards himself and his own dark side. If the doctor wants to guide another, or even accompany him a step of the way, he must feel with that person’s psyche. He never feels it when he passes judgment; whether he puts his judgments into words or keeps them to himself makes not the slightest difference. To take the opposite position and to agree with the patient offhand is also of no use. Feeling comes only through unprejudiced objectivity.

"This sounds almost like a scientific precept. And it could be confused with a purely intellectual abstract attitude of mind. But what I mean is something quite different. It is a human quality: A kind of deep respect for the facts – for the man who suffers from them and for the riddle of such a man’s life. The truly religious person has such an attitude. He knows that God has brought all sort of strange and unconceivable things to pass and seeks in the most curious ways to enter a man’s heart. He therefore senses in everything the unseen presence of the Divine Will. This is what I mean by unprejudiced objectivity. It is a moral achievement on the part of the doctor who ought not to let himself be repelled by sickness and corruption. We cannot change anything unless we accept it. Condemnation does not liberate. It oppresses. And I am the oppressor of the person I condemn – not his friend and fellow sufferer.

"I do not in the least mean to say that we must never pass judgment when we desire to help and improve. But, if the doctor wishes to help a human being, he must be able to accept him as he is. And he can do this in reality only when he has already seen and accepted himself as he is. Perhaps this sounds very simple, but simple things are always the most difficult. In actual life, it requires the greatest art to be simple. And so, acceptance of oneself is the essence of the moral problem, and the acid test of one’s whole outlook on life. That I feed the beggar – that I forgive an insult – that I love my enemy in the name of Christ – all these are undoubtedly great virtues. What I do unto the least of my brethren that I do unto Christ. But what if I should discover that the least amongst them all – the poorest of all beggars – the most impudent of all offenders – yea the very fiend himself – that these are within me? And that I myself stand in need of the arms of my own kindness. That I myself am the enemy that must be loved. What then?

"Then, as a rule, the whole truth of Christianity is reversed. There is then no more talk of love and long suffering. We say to the brother within us: Rocca, and condemn and rage against ourselves. We hide him from the world. We deny ever having met this least among the lowly in ourselves. And had it been God himself who drew near to us in this despicable form, we should have denied him a thousand times before a single cock had crowed."
- Alan Watts on Carl Jung (starting at 7:50)

Friday, September 15, 2017

The brutality of morality

We must be kind and think of others well being. Or must we? Must we think of others first, and never ourselves first? What is it like to think of ourselves first, and not think of others?

What part of me is freed by not always thinking and doing the "right" thing all the time? What can I let go of?

Can I let go of the anger and judgment of others, when they don't live up to my standards? What do other people not allow themselves, that traps them in it's cage, and makes them judge, and cut themselves off from, others?

What is my jail? What makes my jail any better, objectively speaking, than that person who judges people based on their wealth, or that other person over there who judges people based on popularity? Or that person, who judges people based on power? How am I any different? You think your standards are more moral, and therefore you are more moral, because you respect your own values and look down on those others, but your jail is still a jail. A jail is a jail, whether it's made of shit or of gold. You're still unfree.

What is it like to simply live, without shoulds? Without preconceptions, and judgments? What is it like to accept the facts of life, and people, and their ideas, without immediately judging them? What would it be like to live completely open to this life?

The sickness of our time is tied to our excessive valuing of "right" and rejection of "wrong." The differentiation of good and evil that Christianity brought with it was a positive step forward in the development of human consciousness but it's gone on for too long, and to too great a degree. We're seeing the consequences of our excessive one-sidedness now.

To completely reject all that is weak, stupid, selfish, and ridiculous in us - in other words, to reject our own personal, little evil - is to brutalize ourselves and each other. It is inhuman, and, when taken to its logical conclusion, leads to and only can lead to the most horrific and brutal atrocities. The witch trials of Europe; the extermination of Jews, gypsies, homosexuals, and leftists during the Holocaust; and the violence against immigrants and progressives in America today are all the result of this sick one-sidedness. An unconscious shadow is the weak spot where collective evil - true evil - can catch us, and no shadow is darker and more unconscious than that of the moralist. To avoid having such a dark and vulnerable shadow we must become conscious of it. Becoming conscious of ones shadow makes it less dark, but this requires of the conscious self that it give up some of it's brightness, because the darkness has to go somewhere.


Monday, September 4, 2017

The hero sun


The finest of all symbols of the libido is the human figure, conceived as a demon or hero. Here the symbolism leaves the objective, material realm of astral and meteorological images and takes on human form, changing into a figure who passes from joy to sorrow, from sorrow to joy, and, like the sun, now stands high at the zenith and now is plunged into darkest night, only to rise again in new splendor.

The psychic life-force, then libido, symbolizes itself in the sun59 or personifies itself in figures of heroes with solar attributes. At the same time it expresses itself through phallic symbols. Both possibilities are found on a late Babylonia gem from Lajard's collection (fig. 19). In the middle stands an androgynous deity. On the masculine side, there is a snake with a sun halo round its head; on the feminine side another snake with a sickle moon above it. This picture has a symbolic sexual nuance: on the masculine side there is a lozenge, a favourite symbol of the female genitals, and on the feminine side a wheel without its rim. The spokes are thickened at the ends into knobs, which, like the fingers we mentioned earlier, have a phallic meaning. It seems to be a phallic wheel such as was not unknown in antiquity. There are obscene gems on which Cupid is shown turning a wheel consisting entire of phalli60. As to what the sun signifies, I discovered in the collection of antiquities at Verona a late Roman inscription with the following symbols:

The symbolism is plain: sun=phallus, moon = vessel (uterus). The interpretation is confirmed by another monument from the same collection. The symbols are the same, except that the vessel has been replaced by the figure of a woman... From here it is clear that sexuality as well as the sun can be used to symbolize the libido. 

Footnotes:
1. Hence the beautiful name of the sun-hero Gilgamesh, "The Man of Joy and Sorrow," in Jensen, Das Gilgamesch-Epos.
59. Among the elements composing man, the Mithraic liturgy lays particular stress on fire as the divine element, describing it as [Gr. "the divine gift in my composition"]. Dieterich, Mithrasliturgie, p. 58.
60. An illustration of the periodicity or rhythm expressed in sexuality.
- Jung, Aspects of the Masculine, p.3

Saturday, September 2, 2017

A society of animals

In this rather humorous way the unconscious took up the idea, namely that it is really a great problem, for as conscious beings we can contact each other, but in this inferior function, one person is a cat, another is a tortoise, and a third a hare – there are all those animals! Such social adaptations present a great difficulty. There are all the problems of having one’s own territory, one’s own ground, for every animal species has a tendency to have a few meters of homeland. Every bird and every animal defends its territory from intruders; one may not step on the other’s ground, and all these complicated rituals build up again as soon as human beings join together and discard the persona and try really to contact each other. Then one really feels as if one is moving in the jungle or the bush: one must not step on this snake or frighten that bird by making quick movement, and things become very complicated. This need for bush manners has even led to the belief that psychology causes social behavior to deteriorate, which to some extent is quite true. At the Jung Institute, too, we are in a way much nastier and more difficult a group to get along with than, say, a society for breeding dogs or hares, or a club for fishermen, for there the social contact is in general on a much better level. Such an accusation has often been made not only of the Psychology Club but also of the Institute. But the truth is simply that we tend not to cover up what is going on underneath. In all other societies or groups of people, that is covered up and plays under the table; underneath there are all these difficulties, but they are never brought up to the surface and discussed openly. But, in fact, naturally, facing the shadow and the inferior function has the effect that people become socially more difficult and less conventionally adapted, and that creates more friction. On the other hand, it also creates a greater liveliness: it is never boring, for there is always a storm in a teacup and excitement, and the group is very much alive instead of having a dull, conventional, correct surface. It has even gone so far that in the Psychology Club, the animal tendencies to have one’s own realm became so strong that people started reserving seats; there was So and So’s chair, and you couldn’t’ sit on it; that was a major insult, because So and So always sat there. I have noticed that there are also papers on certain chairs on which people write their names: this is my chair – in other words, there the dog or cat So and So sits! That is a very good sign, and I thought; “Well now, that is better, matters are improving!” It is a restoration of an original and natural situation. But it is amazing how deeply the inferior function can connect one down into the realm of animal nature within oneself.

Apart from the humorous way in which I have described it, it is a very important fact, for the inferior function is actually the connection with one’s deepest instincts, with one’s inner roots, and is, so to speak, that which connects us with the whole past of mankind.
Marie Louise von Franz, Psychotherapy

Thursday, August 31, 2017

Symbolism: Eye

This is the first of the aggregator posts on various symbols. Ideally, these posts will contain an overview of the symbol (in the vein of previous posts on symbols) along with links to both outside resources and to posts on 2BiaT of quotes from various Jungian and other books that amplify the symbol. But, seeing how much time and effort writing these overviews takes, many of these will be uploaded without the overview and I will try write one up in the future. This is the first post like that - about the symbol of the eye - I will write up a full overview as soon as I am able.

A similar thing will be done for glossary posts, both future ones and those that have already been done: any posts that relate to a particular topic will be linked to in the glossary post in question.


Posts:

"Telepathy"

Many gods and demons of various mythological culture groups have such a large eye on their breast; thus they see everything that takes place on earth. This motif points to the fact – which we can observe time and again in the analysis of the drams of patients – that the unconscious in us often seems to possess a knowledge of things which were previously inexplicable and which, seen rationally, we cannot know. Such terms as “telepathy” do not explain the phenomenon. But we are able to recognize every day that dreams speak to people of things which they obviously cannot know. The unconscious seems to have something like a diffuse intuitive knowledge which reaches into our surroundings, and which Jung called “absolute knowledge” (because it’s detached from consciousness) or the “luminosity” of the unconscious.
- Marie Louise von Franz, Dreams, p. 9

Wednesday, August 30, 2017

Only the individual can heal the individual, and only the individual can be healed

[T]the medical investigator, thanks to his knowledge of archetypal processes, is in the fortunate position of being able to recognize in the abstruse and grotesque-looking symbolisms of alchemy the nearest relatives of those serial fantasies which underlie the delusions of paranoid schizophrenia as well as the healing processes at work in the psychogenic neuroses. The overweening contempt which other departments of science have for the apparently negligible psychic processes of “pathological individuals” should not deter the doctor in his task of helping and healing the sick. But he can help the sick psyche only when he meets it as the unique psyche of that particular individual, and when he knows its early and unearthly darkness. He should also consider it just as important a task to defend the standpoint of consciousness, clarity, “reason,” and an acknowledged and proven good against the raging torrent that flows for all eternity in the darkness of the psyche – a _____ [Greek phrase] that leaves nothing unaltered and ceaselessly creates a past that can never be retrieved. He knows that there is nothing purely good in the realm of human experience, but also that for many people it is better to be convinced of an absolute good and to listen to the voice of those who espouse the superiority of consciousness and unambiguous thinking. He may solace himself with the thought that one who can join the shadow to the light is the possessor of the greater riches. But he will not fall into the temptation of the law-giver, nor will he pretend to be the prophet of truth: for he knows that the sick, suffering, or helpless patient standing before him is not the public but is Mr. or Mrs. X, and that the doctor has to put something tangible and helpful on the table or he is no doctor. His duty is always to the individual, and he is persuaded that nothing has happened if this individual has not been helped. He is answerable to the individual in the first place and to society only in the second. If he therefore prefers individual treatment to collective ameliorations, this accords with the experience that social and collective influences usually produce only a mass intoxication, and that only man’s action upon man can bring about a real transformation.
- Jung, Aspects of Masculinity, p. 103

Tuesday, August 29, 2017

PSA: New directions for 2BiaT

Apologies to my readers for the hiatus - it was a combination of exhaustion from doing some heavy duty posts, researching material for new posts, getting ready for school, and doing summer stuff (which has included weddings and their attendant festivities). At any rate, I probably won't be able to maintain the two posts per week schedule, especially since I'm starting school this week (Psychology! Hopefully to continue on to my training as a Jungian analyst).

I'm also adjusting the focus of this blog a little. I'd like this to be more of a resource for people doing Jungian-ish kind of work: the glossary and the posts on symbols are great, but I'm also going to do more aggregator-style posts. The two things in particular that I really want to work on - that I really feel would be an amazingly useful resource for people - are posts of quotes about the symbols; analyses of dreams from Jung, von Franz and others; quotes about fairy tales, myths - basically a one-stop-shop for anyone who wants to explore various symbols to interpret their dreams or for other purposes. These posts will be works in progress that expand as I find new material to include.

I'm in the process of gathering information right now but I will be starting to posting these within the next few weeks. Good luck, and I hope you enjoy your Labor day weekend!


Sunday, August 6, 2017

The need for self discipline and a patient attitude

When an impulse from the unconscious comes up, it is always accompanied by a drive to realize it in a concrete manner. This is a general truth. We see this most often, for example, when transference phenomena occur during psychological treatment. When one is a patient and falls in love with one’s doctor and dreams of making love, it is a sign that one needs to experience greater human closeness, a better human contact. But most often a patient gives it a more concrete interpretation and would like to realize it immediately. This is not because of stupidity, but rather we know that “it” within us is driving us. It is a certain demoniacal force, but if it were to be realized in such a concrete manner, the patient would be the first to be disappointed. But one is unable to restrain oneself and does not notice that it is meant to be understood symbolically. This is how it is with most contents from the unconscious. They are always accompanied by this hasty drive to carry the thing out immediately. This is the demon. This means that one must always first of all think about it and say, “Just a moment. Let’s wait and see what wants to be realized.”

In a letter, Jung even went so far as to say “Demonic powers are archetypes in an initial stage of moving toward consciousness.” This means that all archetypes, as they begin to move toward consciousness, have demoniacal aspects. It is only after the threshold into consciousness has been broken through and the content has been integrated that its positive meaning becomes apparent. This also means that that which is demoniacal is not something absolute. Rather, it is a stage to be passed through for those unconscious contents which are moving up toward consciousness. And this explains why it is that creative people are very closely exposed to demonic, devilish forces, for in them, archetypal contents are breaking through the threshold into consciousness. This is also why one very often sees that before there is a creative concretization, there is a creative disturbance and certain demoniacal impulses appear.

... [O]ne has to know that there is a charge inside oneself, but one should not let it take a wrong path, but must contain it until it comes out in the right way. But, of course, this requires strong self-discipline.
Marie Louse von Franz, Creation Myths, p. 151

Wednesday, August 2, 2017

Jung Was Not a Mystic, and Jungianism Is Not Mysticism

Laura London: And it’s important to look at [Wolfgang] Pauli’s dreams because you mention that creative discoveries are usually preceded by the processes appearing in dreams.

Gary Sparks: That’s a whole nother discussion right there. One of the things he tried to do – I’m taking that question and making it a little more specific – the idea that we’re dealing with here is “Is there a way to live that is not based on imposing our will on somebody else?” Technology is basically about imposing our will on matter. And he was interested in seeing is there a way we can live without imposing the will. I think what his dreams are articulating is the critical importance of doing that.

LL: You said that our way of looking at things is going to go through another development.

GS: Yeah, I think it has to. We’ve got to find another way to live, other than the imposition of will; the imposition of will over matter or nature.

LL: And that science and spirituality are going to have to come together. The unconscious says that they’re the same, and that’s where we get stuck. What do you mean by that?

GS: Well, for example Pauli dreamt of going into his lab and a mass was being conducted. Or going into a church and the priest was doing a scientific experiment. In the unconscious there’s no difference between science and religion. I think for me the answer has to do with symbolic living.

The error is thinking that science is a linear, logical process on the scientific side; and on the religious side, that it’s a metaphysical experience beyond rational critiquing. But what Pauli showed, getting back to your earlier question as well, scientific ideas start with an image. He wrote an essay trying to show how some of his theories came out of dream images. So that the symbolic life can be seen at the foundation of science. And a genuine religious life is not belief, but it’s religious experience, based on images that appear within the psyche. So that giving up the idea of science as rational and that religion is metaphysically unarguable, both have to change for the adoption of the symbolic life.

LL: You said that Pauli had a foot in both worlds. Would you say that the same was true of Jung?

GS: Yes, definitely. More toward the end of his life, I think. As I mentioned he would necessarily have devoted his attention to the psyche. At the end of his life... you now they have that tower down in Bollingen? He added the tower, the highest point in the structure, because he realized he hadn’t given enough credence to the ego. He worked intensely on the inner world and then, toward the end of his life, realized the crucial point is how that relates to the outer world. But he needed to focus on the inner world because that was where his research could bear the most fruit, but then toward the end of his life, as I mentioned in that quote of von Franz, said, “Now, how does that relate to the outside material world?”

LL: One of Pauli’s dreams that you look at in your book is his dream of the world clock. You say that the dream was trying to show Pauli that he could not understand life without accepting it’s complexities. .

GS: There’s a [heart] and a vision in the dream of a clock which is on a horizontal plane, and there’s a clock which is on a vertical plane, and they intersect… I think the two are resting on the back of a bird. The Greeks had that all figured out, and we’ve forgotten it, but I think Pauli was dreaming of it. Time has both a qualitative and a quantitative aspect. We’ve lost the idea of the qualitative aspect. That’s what a synchronicity is. And the complexity is revealing we have to both have our feet firmly in time and space; deal with the problems that we’re facing, deal with emotions, deal with conflict. Deal with rage, lust, problems, conflicts. On the one hand that is the horizontal clock. And yet there is a timeless dimension of that, which is the vertical clock would represent.

There are qualitative moments in our life which, if we don’t understand them, we will lose the meaning of everything that happens in that horizontal circle. And the art of living is living with the knowledge of the importance of time and space, and also what transcends time and space.

LL: You said of that dream, “It has been suggested that Pauli looked very closely at the events of his life, and took responsibility for his role in them. This is what ego development is about; absorbing behavior and taking responsibility for it.”

GS: That’s the horizontal clock. That’s why Jung was not a mystic. You know; paying rent, paying mortgages, getting your car fixed, arguing with the car mechanic. As Jung said, I wonder what Christianity would be like if Jesus had three kids to put through college? All of that is very important. It’s only when we are living responsibly to those demands that spirituality really can reach it’s full extent.

LL: And that dream of Pauli’s that we were just speaking of, the one of the world clock, is in a section of the book called “Dual Mandala”.

GS: Yes.

LL: You said, “A dual mandala is a living image which portrays that a single life is made up of two parts: the here and now, and something else.”

GS: Yeah, that something else is that vertical clock. It’s those kairos moments in which we are guided toward our own development, in a way which we cannot rationally understand. Until we can recognize the tension between the two – or similarity between the two – the synching between X, Y, and Z, between the two, we’re only living half a story. Or a very split story.
  - Speaking of Jung, Episode #2: J. Gary Sparks,  38:22 (Laura London)